Is the new Corona Virus Causing the Epidemic Hybridized With HIV?

What do you make of this? How do you interpret this finding?

@davecarlson, @glipsnort, @evograd

1 Like

It was (rightfully) withdrawn by the authors over a week ago.

2 Likes

Great. Why did they withdraw?

Basically, their claims about similarity of the Wuhan virus to HIV were wildly disproportionate to the evidence they presented. They performed a very shallow analysis and found a few short regions within a couple proteins that appeared to align to HIV proteins. The alignments were so short that they were very likely spurious, however.

They took these inconclusive results and then wildly over-intepreted them with sensational language. The whole thing was a giant irresponsible embarrassment that should have never happened.

If it sounds like I’m kinda piqued about this, it’s because I am. This awful manuscript managed to spawn wild conspiracy theories all over the internet. Thankfully, the authors at least acted responsibly enough to withdraw the manuscript after it received a bunch of valid criticism. But the damage was done.

5 Likes

It’s ok though, the preprint only has the highest attention score of any article ever!

2 Likes

It was a POS paper, not a PLOS one.

4 Likes

An interesting bit of background:

A lab strain of coronavirus causing an outbreak isn’t unheard of.

1 Like

You’re probably aware of this, but a major virology institute is located in Wuhan.