Braterman: Darwin Devolves, So What?

[swamidass (S. Joshua Swamidass)]

@Rumraket

and a further leap takes him to the conclusion that the natural processs of mutation and selection cannot create significant function.

This is where I think Behe’s case unhinges.

This is an important point. I is critical to realize that Darwin Devolves is irreducibly complex; requiring both Edge of Evolution and Darwin’s Black Box for support. This makes all three books the subject of conversation right now, and they are a house of cards. If one false, so goes Darwin Devolves.