Comments on Three Reviews at BioLogos

[gbrooks9 (George)]

@swamidass

GAE stands in contrast to sole- genetic progenitor models, but it is a sole- genealogical progenitor model. It stands in contrast with genetic monogenesis models, but it is a genealogical monogenesis model.

@swamidass

I like your clarification except for the use of the term “sole-genealogical progenitor”.

Since a population can have more than one pair of genealogical progenitors, it would seem that your attempt to wedge “sole” into the phrase only works for one type of model: the ones where all possible descendants come from only ONE parent, or from only ONE mated pair.