Critiques of C. S. Lewis

John 1:17?

I wouldn’t classify a calculator as a “non-rational” cause in the sense Lewis intends it, as it was specifically created by rational agents for the precise purpose as to give such answers. If non-rational phenomena somehow managed to create something that resembled or functioned like a calculator, on the other hand…

Mark 14: “Again the high priest asked him, “Are you the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?” **62 **And Jesus said, “I am, and you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power, and coming with the clouds of heaven.” **63 **And the high priest tore his garments and said, “What further witnesses do we need? **64 **You have heard his blasphemy.”

Matthew 25 “When the Son of Man comes in his glory, and all the angels with him, then he will sit on his glorious throne. **32 **Before him will be gathered all the nations, and he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats. **33 **And he will place the sheep on his right, but the goats on the left. **34 **Then the King will say to those on his right, ‘Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world.

You have either not read or have not understood @Tim remarks and the extensive context in which he made them. The “logic” of Lewis’s simplistic trichotomy is not intrinsically flawed insofar as each shallow step leads to the next. I suggest you read what we are saying, and why, before typing tedious unnecessary rehashings of Lewis’s argument. I can assure you that neither @Tim nor any of the other critics of Lewis in this thread are having any trouble following Lewis’s logic.

Thank you. I’ve always thought that John was the most unlikely of the gospels to be based on anything factual, and the worst possible witness to anything Jesus actually said or did. But that does answer my question. I see that @RevGundulf refers to the same passage.

1 Like

Sure, I am staunchly sola Scriptura, but that doesn’t mean I don’t recognize the fact that I see Scripture through a lens, nor that I think those lenses unhelpful. (If for no other reason, it helps us from having to “reinvent the wheel” anytime I go to the Bible). What is insulting is the claim that I wouldn’t or couldn’t see such-and-such doctrine unless I had said particular lens.

My illustration about docetism I think is illustrative. Sure, I read Scripture through the “lens” of the anteNicean fathers who combatted it, no dispute. Yes, that is a helpful lens, and hence I don’t read Scripture with the tendency to even consider “Maybe Jesus simply ‘appeared’ to be physical.'” I instinctively and automatically read Scripture as saying that Jesus was indeed quite real flesh and blood. Docetism is a non-starter for me, both because it is not taught in any church I’ve attended, and because I’ve been explicitly taught it to be a heresy condemned by the early church Fathers.

What I vehemently reject, and would find insulting - would be the suggestion that the only reason I perceive the Bible as affirming Christ as being flesh and blood is because I’m reading it through the lens of the AnteNicean fathers, not because that doctrine is explicit in or logically derivable from the text - and that, had they not established said “lens,” I’d never be able to find anything about Jesus being flesh and blood in Scripture. Good lenses help me see more clearly things that are there, good functioning lenses don’t allow me to see things that aren’t there. Lenses that cause me see things that aren’t there need to be thrown away.

And further, I still profoundly disagree on the other point - to be strictly logical once again, on any given particular of doctrine, Nicea either discovered, catalogued, reformulated, clarified, organized, articulated doctrines from Scripture (either things that were in Scripture, or that are “good and necessary” inferences from Scripture), or - if those doctrines were neither explicit in nor good and necessary inferences from Scripture, then Nicea invented new doctrines.

Or, put another way:

If said framework was a good and necessary deduction gradually deduced by the Fathers, then it WAS contained within Scripture. If it was not a good and necessary deduction (and thus alternate views are in fact perfectly consistent with Scripture), then by definition it was NOT contained in Scripture, is not logically derivable from Scripture, and Nicea had no basis or business condemning Arius for a view that was perfectly logically consistent with Scripture.

Finally, I’m curious why you keep using the very limited language that the Fathers deduced Nicean doctrine from the claims that 1) Jesus was the Messiah and 2) the truest revelation from God… as if the Bible didn’t also make the claims that he “was in very nature God” “was with God and was God,” in whom the “whole fullness of deity dwells,” “exact imprint” etc. of God’s nature, etc. Those seem better Scriptures or concepts for discussing this very questions than simply his claim to messiahship, a relatively vague title that was even given to Cyrus at one point.

One of his claims was simply:

the one moment which led to His execution. The moment at which the high priest said to Him, “Who are you?” “I am the Anointed, the Son of the uncreated God, and you shall see Me appearing at the end of all history as the judge of the Universe.”

The high priest certainly understood said claims as at minimum justifying the charge of blasphemy. I’ll let you say how similar you think those two claims are. But either way for this discussion, those are indeed rather extraordinary claims.

I think this is a confusion between two sorts of causes: the causes of the origin of a thing and the causes of its operation. A calculator operates entirely through physical causation requiring no outside intervention. It of course required manufacture initially, but no intelligence is needed thereafter for it to operate. You seem to be arguing that for the human intellect, both divine creation initially and some kind of supernatural causation subsequently in the mind’s workings are required. But these are separable claims and should be considered separately. The calculator analogy was intended to argue about the second claim, of operation. Bringing up the first claim is not relevant.

Bible quotes: valid point, though not for the stronger claim that Jesus claimed to be God. Here, he is God’s son, unless you read through a trinitarian lens. Probably close enough for Lewis’s main purpose, though. Assuming those actually are the words of Jesus, of course. Anyway, being delusional and being a great moral teacher are not mutually exclusive, which destroys his point.

3 Likes

That applies to the latter four, I agree. But not to Muhammad. I was actually thinking of bringing him up, so I am glad you did so yourself. His claims are not identical to those of Jesus. He never claimed to be God, himself. But he did claim to be receiving messages directly from God and, in that sense, placed himself in the same category as Jesus (according to Islam, which also considers Jesus to be a non-divine messenger of God.)

Muhammad, like Jesus, is one of history’s most important and influenctial moral teachers. I would go so far as to say he was far more influential, since he achieved this position during his lifetime, and not posthumously thru his followers. And Lewis’s trilemma applies just as well to Muhammad as it does to Jesus: Muhammad either really did receive messages from God, was lying or was mistaken. But Lewis is committed to rejecting “messenger of God” and is stuck with choosing bertween “liar” or “lunatic” (Admittedly, this version of the trilemma is weaker than Lewis’s for its lack of alliteration).

If such a position is problematic for someone who rejects the divinity of Jesus, is it not equally problematic for Lewis when he takes that position WRT Muhammad?

What evidence would that be? The stories told about Jesus by some of his devoted followers? Why on earth should we consider those to be reliable?

Well, of course not, because the evidence we have is highly biased. If every single piece of documentation about Koresh disappeared except what was written by his most devoted and besotted followers, don’t you think he would also come across as a wise and rational moral teacher?

I wrote a post with a video of Marshall Applewhite, the leader of the Heaven’s Gate cult, but you may have missed it because of the delay in posting comments here. I can only speak for myself, but I cannot fathom anyone being able to listen to more than a minute of his incoherent blathering before making an excuse to walk out. But dozens of people found him so persuasive and inspiring that they were willing to fatally poison themselves. Oh, but only after they had first allowed themselve to be castrated.

My point is that the fact a group of people considered someone to be a wise moral teacher is not reliable evidence the he actually wasone. Especially when that group is a cult that has cut itself off from the rest of society and is strongly under the leader’s influence. (And, to be clear, I am not assuming that the leader in question was Jesus himself. We know next to nothing about what went on among the earliest Christians after his death and how the beliefs that led to the religion that bears his name first arose.)

1 Like