It should be noted that Behe has had 28 years, since he published Darwin’s Black Box, to come up with a well-defined position or model. He is now 72. I think the probability that he dies of old age before he makes a further attempt at doing so is not insubstantial.
1 Like
By “you”, I presume you are referring to atheists who reject Behe’s claims in general. I’m pretty sure Behe does not even know I exist (Thought I can’t be certain, since some ID’ers have blogged about me).
Regardless, by describing his position as “inscrutable”, you are agreeing that he has yet to clearly articulate his position. And, as @Tim points out, it is extremely unlikely Behe ever will.
That gets back to my point that Behe’s writing are to be understood as propaganda and rhetoric, not as serious scientific or philosophical thought.
2 Likes
I showed you a blatant case of exactly that above. Do you think I’m lying?
@gbrooks9, Eddie has not replied to your post.
Do you think he read your post? Do you think he read your e-mailed notice?
Do we even know if he even receives email notices? I turned them off years ago, as I found them to be a useless nuisance. Incidentally Eddie was last “seen” (as in logged onto the forum) on 29 March.
1 Like
Yes, I do. Otherwise, I would have to conclude he has powers of ESP.