Dr Behe: Scenario of "God's Pool Shot"

[gbrooks9 (GeorgeB)]

@Eddie

Under the pool ball analogy , Jonah would have to become as passive and obedient as a pool ball is when struck by another pool ball. He would do exactly what God said, exactly when God asked him, but he would be like a programmed android in a science fiction story, presenting the similitude of being human while all the while functioning like a machine. And I was agreeing with you that God has not created human beings to be that way, but allows them the freedom to make difficulties, put up resistance, procrastinate, evade, waver, etc.

@Eddie

So now you are trying to con your audience into “what Jonah must do”… and youve turned him into an automaton ?

I can tell you right now… that is not in Behe’s model if he ever produces one that is post-human emergence… nor is it in mine.

You could say: "some low intellect individuals might imagine this is the only way to interpret the pool shot scenario in the presence of humanity… but there are other more reasonable interpretations!