@vjtorley, we are covering this right here: Miller: Axe Decisively Confirmed?
It seems clear that despite the titling of the article, there are some large concessions being made, and large gaps in the science.
See the thread for more discussion.
Much of what comes out of ENV is theatre, but they sometimes have science embedded within it. The best thing to do is just tune out the theatrical parts of the paper. They are always going to claim grand success, no matter what. They essentially never (though individuals have done better) directly concede. So it takes work to understand what to really make of it.