You are also overlooking a very important fact: No one doubts that large asteroids hit planets. Whereas there is no conclusive, or even particularly convincing, evidence that any supernatural event ever happens or has happened, at any time or place. This is why the consensus of scholars in many fields is against the consideration of “supernatural” occurrences as explanation, even among those who might believe in the supernatural as a matter of personal faith.
This is yet another important consideration that Andrew tries to just blithely skim over. His argument actually requires that one accept as an established fact that supernatural things occur. Completely unjustified.