Um, not everything is about you! And starting with mentioning “an atheist”, obviously to then say “you” would be turning to address the unidentified atheist, directly. This is actually done in English.
Yes, I have used Hoyle’s 747 analogy here at times, but the quote I did, which was said to be referencing Hoyle’s analogy, was actually about a super-intellect monkeying with physics, etc., there was no analogy in it.