Silverswords Fail the Species Pair Challenge

[Dan_Eastwood]

Gotta love that ID model of engagement. First refuse any form of open discourse, then complain when others openly discuss ID claims. I offered to set up some sort of “visiting scholar” discussion, but he didn’t mention that.

@Bechly writes

This forum is dominated mainly by the very same group of hardcore anti-ID activists (such as Joe Felsenstein, John Harshman, Arthur Hunt, Puck Mendelssohn, and “Rumraket”) who are notorious for their vitriolic attacks against intelligent design proponents at other Darwinist forums like Panda’s Thumb.

Well then who he is willing to talk to, if not the people most knowledgeable about ID? Maybe he should go to UD where anyone doubting ID gets banned, and he can bask in the glowing appreciation of no criticism at all.

Also, it looks to me that he still didn’t define any terms which would allow his challenge to be met, as predicted by @structureoftruth:

@structureoftruth

Honestly I would not be surprised if every example he was offered was met with a similar response. (Otters and ferrets: not different enough! Silverswords: plants don’t count!)