Why are We Disagreeing with ID?

[Mercer (John Mercer)]

@Faizal_Ali

But Behe said there were no new protein complexes. Wrote it in a book. Then an undergrad spent a few minutes on the internet and found a new protein complex.

Well, not really. Anyone could have spent a few minutes on the internet to learn that Behe’s claim was false when it was made. At the time, Dr. Smith (for you, @Eddie) was an undergrad who worked on HIV.

@Faizal_Ali

So when Behe says there are no other new protein complexes anywhere because he says so, should we believe him?

And when @lee_merrill claims:

@lee_merrill

Well, the Vpu function in HIV came up after Behe wrote his book…

Should anyone believe it?