Wayne Rossiter is an important case study. He wrote recently:
I also had some private conversation with Joshua Swamidass. Very encouraging stuff. I think I was too hard on him in previous posts. He and I probably won’t agree on everything, but I want to say that I think he is an authentic seeker of the kingdom of God, believing in His miraculous power and salvation through Jesus Christ. More on these, and other convictions of sin, to come. Take care out there. God bless.
He, interestingly enough, is a theistic evolutionist. He affirms common descent and an old earth. His issue is not with evolution but specifically with the BioLogos theological agenda. He is a person to watch closely going forward.
[Edit: removed mistaken claim that he left ID]