I’ve been on this site since its inception but only post in occasional spurts. I’ve been following ID since the 80s and I’ve always been a bit dismayed there is no comprehensive source for the arguments for evolution and against ID. When I’ve commented on this on various sites people always refer me to the talk.origins website but this has only the most superficial information. Due to the hard work and rhetorical skill of IDers there is a labyrinth of arguments, counter-arguments, counter-counter arguments etc. on each topic. I’ve been thinking recently of tackling one such topic on my Youtube channel : protein evolution
It seems to me that protein evolution is the crux of the whole debate. If one can show to non-biologists that proteins are ‘evolvable’ and the evidence that they have been evolving that would go a long way to settling the debate, at least to reasonable people. When I think of putting together something like this it seems impossibly daunting, but it occurred to me others might like to be involved. Many of the relevant topics have been discussed here so either way I’d incorporate insights in these discussions. I’m thinking this could be done in a few videos or one marathon video along the lines of Erika/Will Duffy. If anyone would like to discuss respond here at email me at roderick.wilson@uconn.edu
I dont have my notes with me but a general outline would be:
Basic structure of proteins including motifs, domains and modules; how proteins perform their functions. proteins families, evolution of protein structure ie monomers to multimers, allostery etc, ancestral reconstruction, antibodies, abzymes, phage display, evolutions of new functions, origin of proteins ie catalytic RNA, peptides etc.
BTW, I have 2 videos on my channel. One is a ‘journal club’ on the Alu insertion that led to tail loss in primates. The other is my take on why the ‘Waiting Time Problem’ argument doesnt work. If anyone would take a look and give me feedback id be very appreciative. I’m not at all happy on how they turned out but I think I can improve on presentation and style in the future.
One good resource for protein phylogenies is the Orthomam site: https://orthomam.mbb.cnrs.fr
It has sequence alignments` and phylogenies for both amino acid sequences and coding sequences. These are for all known completely-sequenced mammalian genomes. Currently for 15,868 gene families.
You can use it to compare phylogenies for different gene families. As alignments are available, one can either use their precomputed phylogenies or infer them yourself. Each phylogeny is computed from that gene family only – this is not just a matter of them fitting the particular genes onto one overall phylogeny.
The interface needs to be made simpler, but it is possible to teach oneself to download from it. It becomes easy to see that one starts to get close to the same phylogeny as one considers bigger and bigger sets of loci, and that different sets approach the same phylogeny.
Of course creationists immediately wave their hands and say “there are lots of problems with the trees”, without wanting to really get into that. And they also say “it could be common design”. Without getting into whether there is anything that isn’t predicted by common design.
Hiya! I’m not up for essentially re-writing textbooks on all things protein, but I have thought/worked a bit on protein homology and protein phylogeny, drop me an email if interested…
I can make useful comments on the Waiting Problem, in particular to how IDC uses their math. What I can offer might not be as useful as what Joel or someone well verse in population genetics can offer, but I can get into some of the relevant statistical theory that applies.
Hi Dan
Thanks for the offer!! As I suggest in the video we don’t know enough about the relevant processes controlling tissue and organ morphogenesis to apply precise numbers but we know enough to say that there’s nothing implausible about morphological evolution and the IDers/creationists are essentially using a strawman. Do you agree?
Any comments on the video? Be as brutal as you must!!
Rod
First I do believe ID has some strong arguments especially regarding the observation of complex arrangements in the living cell. I watched the beginning of your video and was impressed you were establishing the simple to complex model as that is generally assumed. While chemistry and physics itself can explain the movement from simple to complex structures the ID argument that is powerful is where complex structures can no longer be assigned to chemistry and physics alone like DNA sequences. What ID is attacking is the Darwinian mechanism of random mutation and natural selection. This is where several biologists are trying find new mechanisms that can better explain how more complex changes can occur as a result of the reproductive process and its associated variation.
Not many people know that Phylogenes was the Greek god of well-organized family reunions. His liaison with Homologia (goddess of striking family resemblances) produced the twins Taxon and Taxa, and he eventually adopted the proudly non-binary foundling, Polytome. The extended family included Synapomorphe and Monophyletes, who worked together to fend off the party-crashing Homoplase, an unrelated look-alike, whom their cousin Polyphyletes kept welcoming as kin. All in all, it took the vigilant efforts of family matriarch, Parsimone, to keep the reunions from falling apart at the seams.
Your premise is that there is a “debate” that has “evidence that they have been evolving” as a major focus, among a population that includes “reasonable people.” My impression is significantly different: I don’t see much of a debate at all, maybe because I think of that word (“debate”) as a good thing that involves point/counterpoint exhanges among people of at least average intellectual integrity. I might be overinterpreting your words, and I am certainly not saying that educational projects are worthless or that there aren’t some people who are genuinely curious about the claims of the ID movement. But FWIW, I don’t see refutation of ID propaganda as something involving “debate.”
Is protein evolution “the crux of the whole debate”? I would say “no, not even close.” With that said, I think you find a lot of interest in protein evolution on PS, including specific threads devoted to the topic.
No, we absolutely can’t put good numbers on that sort of thing, and neither can they.
Briefly, statistical inference is based on Likelihood ratios, a ratio of two probabilities for competing hypotheses where the same data is evaluated for each, giving the two probabilities. The part of the math they know how to do, that gives them that small probability, is very much like half of a Likelihood ratio test. IDC doesn’t have a hypothesis to evaluate, so they never calculate a probability, they just assume it is true with probability equal 1.0. plugging that in to get a ratio. (This can be shown more formally as a Bayes Factor).
All “Evolution is mathematically impossible” claims are a Circular argument in mathematical where they assume what they wish to conclude.
They also mischaracterize how the parts of the math that we can do correctly should be done for waiting times; one-at-a-time mutations, no existing variability in the population to begin with, and that one new allele only allows for one new trait (it’s a Power law).
I got pulled away, but I’ll get back to it today. My main SELF-criticism is I don’t know enough biology to follow some of what you are saying.
[quote=“AllenWitmerMiller, post:8, topic:18146”]
All in all, it took the vigilant efforts of family matriarch, Parsimone, to keep the reunions from falling apart at the seams.
[/quote]
She also worked to exclude family members she didn’t like, such as Distance, Likele and Bayese.
@Rod
Stephen makes a good point. Any debate of ID as a scientific concept is tactic acceptance of a scientific concept to be debated. Without a hypothesis, that shouldn’t happen.
An alternative is to simply discuss the science as we understand it, and point to successful results we can put to use. If the science as we know it it wrong, then that shouldn’t work, we shouldn’t be able to very hypotheses, and we should be able to apply the results. The challenge of IDC is to show where IDC hypotheses can do better.
And they don’t do hypotheses.
This approach takes away the main IDC argument that we do not know everything, therefore it must be IDC. They know even less than we do, and have no better alternatives to offer.
Shorter: IDC is apologetics, not science. If it were science they would generate hypotheses and test them.
Careful—exclude too many relatives and the whole family tree goes paraphyletic. Though in fairness, Uncle Bayese couldn’t even make an appearance without bringing up his priors. Besides, she probably only kicked them out to make room at the table for those two eccentric, fast-changing cousins who somehow always end up sitting next to each other no matter how distantly related they actually are.
{@Joe_Felsenstein, the more I thought about your reply, the more I recognized the brilliant layering of your quip. Kudos! By the way, I went back and fixed/improved the Homoplase line}
One practical framing: make the series about how protein evolvability is measured, not about ID’s claims. Use concrete categories like experimental enzyme evolution, ancestral sequence reconstruction, and deep mutational scanning to show what biologists actually do; then address ID objections as footnotes. That avoids granting a “debate” frame while giving viewers testable evidence. For the outline, I’d lead with structure/function and evolvability assays, then move to origin-of-proteins questions.