Did humans evolve as a population?

I think my position is nuanced, and has been explained in detail over the last couple years. Perhaps you’d like to review by reading this: Heliocentric Certainty Against a Bottleneck of Two?, and also, of course my new book: The Genealogical Adam and Eve, or my PSCF article, https://asa3.org/ASA/PSCF/2018/PSCF3-18Swamidass.pdf.

At this time, I do not have more to add.

No. I did answer the question. Many many times.

To answer this question, I’ve published a peer reviewed article on this, explained it precisely in public at professional risk, and have a book coming out next week. Much of this is on the PS and BL forums, though certainly not all of it.

I have made a strong enough case for well-defined (and limited) clams to convince scientists that have reviewed my work, and also philosophers of biology. With so much peer-reviewed and published work out there now, I don’t have anything more to add on an ad hoc basis. If you have any questions about what I’ve written in this body of work, I’ll consider clarifying.