Is belief or unbelief more reasonable?

[thoughtful (Valerie (non-scientist))]

@ProfBravus

Essentially every religious tradition, with the possible exception of the Baha’i faith and some forms of Buddhism, makes this exclusivity claim. Why do you choose to accept it from one religion and reject it from all the rest?

You can follow this thread if you want. The logic of Euthyphro’s Dilemma shows that a moral God can only be good in and of Himself. Only Christianity claims such a god.

Logic also shows that an immoral god would make us unable to determine that he was immoral.

Therefore, the God of Christianity is the only God that can exist.

@thoughtful

I’ve kind of liked working through this argument because it shows one either has to choose the God of Christianity or no god at all, unless there are religions out there I’m unaware of that the Gods love us just because. Other gods cannot exist unless they are evil.

As I understand them, Islam and current Judaism do not affirm this, so they’re out. Their God makes morality independent of God.