Kleinman: Four Questions About Evolution

[swamidass (S. Joshua Swamidass)]

@kleinman

I’m asking for a demonstration as we asked you, not by quoting a paper like this.

You want me to demonstrate what is not happening?

No. Once again…

@swamidass

Your challenge is to identify a well specified question, answerable with a simulation, where you and the experts here disagree on the results. Several outcomes are possible from this experiment.

1. You will not be able to find such a case, which would demonstrate you cannot substabtiate any of your disagreements are salient.
2. Your prediction on the experimental results could be correct, and ours would be wrong. We would learn something.
3. Your prediction is wrong, and ours is right. You would learn something.
4. You will ignore this test of your work, missing your best opportunity in a long time to be heard.

So, let’s see how this plays out. Please produce the parameters of a well specified experiment, and a prediction we can verify with simulation. Check to be sure we are making a different prediction than you. The. Let’s put it to the test.