The Argument Clinic

[Mercer (John Mercer)]

@Sam

Not particularly. I’d be surprised that there aren’t some. Would you be surprised to find some "big Dawkins fans here?

Yes, that prompted my comment.

@Sam

@Mercer

If not, why bring him up instead of having an actual discussion with the people here?

Well to start with, I was directing the comment to an individual person.

I know. Is that person a Dawkins fan?

@Sam

Is that a problem for you? Why the offense?

Those are my questions for you.

@Sam

And I was desiring to see how Dawkins’s materialist view of there being no good, fit with faded Glory’s idea that love is an abstraction.

That didn’t come across very well.