The God of Time

[PdotdQ]

@Patrick

Science is neutral on the existence of God. Therefore when doing science under MN, God is and must be outside of four dimensional spacetime which is all that is or was or ever will be.

In addition to @swamidass’s objections:

Science being neutral on the existence of God does not imply MN. Further, MN does not imply that God must be outside of 4-spacetime.

A trivial counterexample of your claim is a God that exists in every instance of time in which he sustains a superdeterministic universe. Personally I do not subscribe to such a model, but such God is:

1. Within time
2. Satisfies classical definitions of God, such as omniscience and omnipotent
3. Invisible to science
4. Further, depending on which formulation of MN you subscribe to, it is either false in this universe or is tautological

@Patrick

Look at Noether’s theorem. It leads to all the conversation laws in physics. God has to be outside of time for conservation laws of energy to work.

I am not sure where you get this from Noether’s theorem. Noether’s theorem (which by the way, does not lead “to all the conservation laws in physics”) says no such thing.