A Genealogical Adam and Noah

[swamidass (S. Joshua Swamidass)]

@swamidass

If God made humans with common descent, there is zero reason to object to him making other animals by common descent. There is precisely zero people arguing simultaneously that (1) Cambrian explosion was not be common descent, but (2) human evolution was by common descent. That would be a totally incoherent position. This is why it makes most sense to focus on human evolution, where the theological challenges are greatest, and the scientific evidence is strongest.

Revealed_Cosmology:

Well now that is a very strong point. I agree with you that this would seem incoherent. I don’t think that this is what happened.

And in Human evolution, there is just an immense amount of evidence for it, with far more certainty than we see for the Cambrian Explosion. You do not have to agree with it, but that is the place to focus the conversation if you want to get to the bottom of what the evidence shows.

If you read on that Cambrian Explosion thread, you will eventually get here.