In response to creationist misrepresentations they changed the website

This one will be funny to our recent participants in the recent Genetic Entropy and Kondrashov’s paradox-threads, here, here, and here.

Quick recap: Actual population geneticist Dr. Zach Hancock and creationist apologist Paul Price had a debate about the pseudoscientific concept of Genetic Entropy, invented by YEC John Sanford. After the debate, we had some threads where posters on this forum (including Dr. Hancock) discussed both the debate itself and continued arguing with Paul about genetic entropy.

During the course of these discussions, Paul Price invoked something they write on the Masel Lab’s website, that concerning Kondrashov’s paradox; “We still don’t have an answer.”

I told Paul that I thought in fact there were lots of candidate answers, and it might simply be a matter of the population genetics community reaching a consensus about which of the many possibilities it the right one(s).

Later Paul then suggested that the Masel lab had ruled out epistasis altogether as a factor in resolving Kondrashov’s paradox:

Although it’s worth noting that Dr. Masel seems to have ruled out epistasis altogether if you read her website. She basically discounts the idea that epistasis is much of a factor at all.

At the time of the discussion(this link is to the wayback machine), the Masel Lab website said the following concerning Kondrashov’s paradox:

Mutation load

In the title of a 1995 paper, Alexey Kondrashov posed the puzzle “Why have we not died 100 times over?”. We still don’t have an answer. It should take one selective death to purge one new deleterious mutation, but the mean number of new deleterious mutations per human seems to be more than 2, exceeding the number of selective deaths available. Most work on mutation load periodically renormalizes relative fitness to deal with the fact that fitness keeps declining no matter what, or else treats only a subset of the genome. Either way, this is dodging the problem, not tackling its fundamentals, which are not specific to human mutation rates or to small population sizes. One historical solution to the mutation load paradox was synergistic epistasis, often modeled in extreme forms such as truncation selection. Since then, data has come out showing that the mean effects of two deleterious mutations are extraordinarily close to multiplicative. We are exploring models by which very weak epistasis (compatible with data) might be sufficient and/or a “ratchet” occurs in which many small-effect deleterious fixations are counterbalanced by a much smaller number of large-effect beneficial fixations.

I’ve highlighted the sentence in bold that Paul was so obsessed with during those discussions.

Well, since I thought Paul was putting a ridiculous amount of emphasis on the value of the sorts of off-hand remarks and speculations he could find on various websites, news articles, and in the introductions to papers, etc., I wrote Joanna Masel to get her actual take on the matter. Was Paul right to suggest they had actually “ruled out epistasis altogether”? She was kind enough to respond with the following, which I also posted in the thread:

Kondrashov believed the solution was epistasis, specifically what I would call “negative epistasis” rather than “diminishing returns epistasis”. The latter term is usually used for a series of beneficial alleles, the former term is more general, including the case of diminishing returns epistasis but also including a series of deleterious alleles or a mixture of beneficial and deleterious. When low fitness makes compensatory beneficial mutations more frequent, that is described by a different term, namely “sign epistasis”, meaning that the same mutation that is deleterious in one context is beneficial in another. It’s a real thing, with perhaps the clearest evidence being this paper: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adn0753. My lab has not “ruled out epistasis altogether”. Measurements put average negative epistasis among deleterious mutations as being of very small magnitude and I don’t think would be enough in a world where each deleterious mutation needed to be compensated by one beneficial mutation. But sign epistasis can certainly be an important part of the solution, as could negative epistasis (=diminishing returns) among beneficial mutations. The solution in our preprint was that a smaller number of large effect beneficial mutations compensate for many smaller effect deleterious mutations. Mechanisms that increase the number and size of beneficial mutations, as you propose, would interact synergistically with what we proposed to produce an even stronger solution.

That was more or less the end of that, I think, to any reasonable observer. But I coincidentally checked up on the Masel website recently and found it now says the following instad: Masel Lab - Genetic load

Mutation load

In the title of a 1995 paper, Alexey Kondrashov posed the puzzle “Why have we not died 100 times over?”. Simple reasoning suggests that it should take one selective death to purge one new deleterious mutation, but the mean number of new deleterious mutations per human seems to be more than 2, exceeding the number of selective deaths available. Most work on mutation load periodically renormalizes relative fitness to deal with the fact that fitness keeps declining no matter what, or else treats only a subset of the genome. Either way, this is dodging the problem, not tackling its fundamentals, which are not specific to human mutation rates or to small population sizes. One historical solution to the mutation load paradox was synergistic epistasis, often modeled in extreme forms such as truncation selection. Since then, data has come out showing that the mean effects of two deleterious mutations are extraordinarily close to multiplicative.

We think the answer is a “ratchet” in which many small-effect deleterious fixations are counterbalanced by a much smaller number of large-effect beneficial fixations (Matheson et al. 2025a). This has some similarities with “drift barrier theory”, but emphasizes that the cause of the ratchet is not small population size, but a high genome-wide deleterious mutation rate.

We are also

  • exploring the impact of weak global epistasis, compatible with data

  • improving empirical estimates of the genome-wide deleterious mutation rate, to see how far about 1 it is in humans, and what sort of mutations contribute the most

  • studying the evolution of mutation rate

My bolds.

Not only is the sentence about them “still not having an answer” gone, it’s been updated to explicitly say they belive they have an answer.

I guess Paul will have to stop referring to the Masel Lab’s website now.

That’s it. Have fun.