I don’t think I said that the theists on this forum were “disciplined”.
My point was that old habits die hard … and theists and atheists are used to arguing over the very existence of God.
But Peaceful Science is a group that is premised on the existence of God. So when a YEC tries to start a thread challenging the view that Evolution doesn’t need God, too many times too many participants get sucked into the same old disputation cycle.
And the same can be said for those who argue that Evolution works fine without the presence of deity… suddenly you get Creationists trying to prove God must exist.
These two themes are divisive and build animosity. I do not say we should ban these discussions. But I propose that whenever a thread is warned without any success, such threads should be put in the “Eternal Questions” folder.
As you know … we don’t have an Eternal Questions folder!