I like that he mentions my blog series, dismissing it out of hand.
In his article, MacMillan supports the last sentence in the quote above with a link to a specific evolutionary blog33 that critiques my book Replacing Darwin .34 With regards to this specific blog that MacMillan cites as a source for “refutations,” it’s not clear why he picks this one. The author is not a PhD biologist but an evolutionary biology graduate student. This student has publicly admitted a lack of expertise35 on the key subject matter in my book. As a result, at least one theistic evolutionist, when confronted with student’s own admissions, has declined to defend the student’s blog.36
I’ve already responded to this dismissal because of my “lack of expertise” in this comment:
And I think it’s a bit of stretch to interpret this comment of Josh’s:
as “declining to defend the student’s blog”.
Jeanson, or anyone else for that matter, is welcome to correct any errors that I’ve made in my blog posts. The fact that he hasn’t speaks volumes.