Puck's Criticism of Richard Weikart's Book on Racism

[John_Harshman]

I see you have de-flounced. Nothing seems worthy of reply except this bit:

@Eddie

By that reasoning, you’d have to have read everything ever written by the post-Ph.D. John Harshman before you could safely say that the post-Ph.D. Harshman would never have argued that whales were a type of fish because they lived in the water.

I have argued that whales are a type of fish, though not because they live in the water. They’re a type of fish because they belong to Sarcopterygii, Osteichthyes, and Craniata.