The Evidence against the 'Israelites-from-Indus' thesis

[Tim]

@riversea

• So Alice describes Africa, while Bharat describes the Indus Valley, where the Hebrews left. Am I understanding correctly, @OneGod What differentiates Alice’s thinking from Bharat’s?
• About languages: Bharat told me about Pieo and how languages spread. German spread westward, while Sanskrit spread eastward. However, who wrote the Pentateuch while languages were evolving?

Bharat Jhunjhunwala is the author of this whole ‘Common Prophets’/Isrealites-from-Indus’ nonsense. He appears to have no background in Linguistics, History, Anthropology, or any other relevant field. So his opinions would appear to based more on a desire to shoehorn the Indus into the Exodus narrative than on the evidence. Based on the similarity to Bharat’s posts on Biologos, I have the strong suspicion that he is @OneGod.