Continuing from this old discussion a few months ago: Maybe We Will Wiki?
I’ve created a new page on the wiki, Directory of Useful Discussion Threads - Peaceful Science where I’ve listed some of the interesting discussion threads here. People who have time should keep adding to the list. It would be good to have this as a reference when we are arguing topics which have already been argued in depth.
I would advocate that only threads which have less than 150 posts (with not much noise) be added there, so that new users can realistically read them and get something out of it.
I think a good thing to add would be the discussion threads on Behe’s book Darwin Devolves which sprung up a few months ago. I was not involved in those discussions, so someone who was should. It could be a good resource for someone new.